In May 2025, the BBC announced a £40 million contract with outsourcing giant Serco to develop an AI-powered system for handling audience complaints (The Telegraph). The move is bold - and controversial. While it promises faster response times and improved efficiency, it also raises critical questions about where automation belongs and where the human touch must remain.

The plan is to use generative AI to scan, sort, and respond to incoming complaints from BBC viewers and listeners. For one of the UK’s most trusted public institutions, outsourcing and automating this sensitive channel hasn’t gone unnoticed. Concerns about transparency, tone, and public trust are front and centre.

So what’s really at stake here?

Efficiency vs Empathy: the AI trade-off

Public service organisations are under pressure to scale operations while keeping costs down. Automating repetitive, text-heavy tasks - like reading and categorising complaint messages - makes sense on paper. But this isn't just data. These are human voices, often expressing frustration, confusion, or concern.

Poorly tuned AI, or a misread tone, could turn a solvable problem into a PR disaster. On the other hand, well-implemented AI can triage thousands of messages, prioritise urgent issues, and free up staff to personally handle the cases that matter most. The challenge isn’t whether AI should help - it’s how.

What this means for the future of human-AI communication

BBC’s move isn’t isolated. From customer support to internal HR, organisations are exploring AI as a frontline responder. The key to long-term success lies in:

• Maintaining transparency in how AI is used
• Giving users clear options to escalate to a human
• Ensuring security and data governance, especially in sensitive environments
• Preserving a sense of empathy, clarity, and tone - even when the response is machine-generated

It’s not just about “saving time.” It’s about not losing trust.

Where Ulla fits into the bigger picture

At Ulla, we watch moves like BBC’s with interest - and caution. We believe AI should help organisations scale without sacrificing the human connection. Ulla doesn’t replace people. Instead, it takes the friction out of tasks like meeting transcription, summarisation, and data handoff - so professionals can focus on where they’re needed most.

And with options for on-premises deployment, no OpenAI integration, and full data ownership, we make sure automation never comes at the cost of control or compliance.

BBC’s new direction opens the floor to a deeper conversation - not just about automation, but about responsibility. And we’re listening.

✨ Try Ulla